Girlfriend mother's day

Hello, my girlfriend asked me to post this here cuz she don't use Reddit. She's thinking about buying her mom some foundation for mother's day but she doesn't have much money right now, so she can't afford high end products

She's been researching online and though these were good options, but she's very uneasy about the real quality, she would highly appreciate if she could get raw opinions on them and/or other recommendations, they need to be sweat-proof, for oily skin, transfer-proof and suitable for mature skins