Is it wrong to return an eyeshadow palette to Sephora after using it once?

​

Hi everyone, I need some opinions because I’m feeling kinda guilty 😅

I went into Sephora this week looking for a new neutral eyeshadow palette. For YEARS I’ve been using a DIY MAC palette with Omega, Espresso, and Woodwinked and I finally decided it was time to try something new.

While I was there, an employee helped me pick out the YSL Captivating Dunes palette. She told me it was buildable and wouldn’t be too dark, so I trusted it and bought it.

But once I got home and tried it (only one look), it’s definitely darker and smokier than I expected, especially on my fair skin. I feel like it’s just not the vibe I wanted for an everyday neutral palette.

Now I’m debating returning it, but I feel bad because it’s expensive and I technically used it once.

Would it be rude/wrong to return an eyeshadow palette to Sephora after one use if it just doesn’t suit you?

Also—if anyone has recommendations for a lighter neutral palette that gives MAC Omega/Espresso/Woodwinked vibes, I’d love suggestions!