Undecided between Punta Cana all-inclusive, Isla Mujeres or Porto de Galinhas – Help us choose!

Hey everyone! My partner and I (both 30, from Argentina) are planning a beach vacation and can't make up our minds. We love warm, clear water beaches (Caribbean or Brazil-style), good food, great service, and a relaxed vibe. Not looking for a party destination, just a proper chill trip.

Our budget: ~$4,500 USD for two people, flights included. We're based in Argentina, so international flights take a good chunk of that.

The options we're considering:

• Punta Cana, Dominican Republic (all-inclusive, 8 nights): We keep reading mixed reviews about resorts in our budget range, especially regarding food quality. Anyone been to a resort they'd genuinely recommend at this price point?
• Isla Mujeres, Mexico (8 nights): Love the idea of a more laid-back vibe and the freedom to eat at local restaurants. Is it worth it compared to Cancún or Tulum?
• Porto de Galinhas, Brazil (10 nights): We've already been and loved it , the "Brazilian Caribbean" Would go back, but we'd prefer something new if possible.

We're also open to other destinations if you think the budget allows for something even better. Greece, Southeast Asia, Croatia hit us with your suggestions!

Thanks in advance