Eyebrow pencil

I’m so frustrated because Benefit has officially discontinued its manually sharpened eyebrow pencil, which I loved. I knew it was coming so I’d ordered a bunch to last me awhile while I looked for an alternative, but I’ve had no luck in finding anything that comes close. I’m trying the Anastasia Beverly Hills eyebrow pencil currently, but I can’t stand it. The lines aren’t as crisp as I’m used to, no matter how fine a point I’ve sharpened the pencil to. It almost feels like it’s too waxy to give a crisp line instead of a smudge, and it’s driving me nuts. I have really sparse brows and unfortunately grew up in the late 90s/early 2000s and over plucked my poor brows, so I need something that I can use to make my brows look as natural as possible. I do prefer the manually sharpened/old school style of brow pencil because I can’t seem to get as fine a line with the crank up pencils. If anyone has any recommendations I would be so appreciative!