Aruba, Bahamas, Cancun, and Rosemary Beach

My wife and I have narrowed down our choices for our one year anniversary trip to Aruba, the Bahamas Cancun or Rosemary Beach in Florida. We haven’t done a ton of travel. We went to the sanctuary at Cap Cana for our honeymoon. It was amazing. We’re pretty simple people. Free drinks decent food and a lot of relaxation.

We are deciding between one of the above for our anniversary trip. All inclusive would be great if we went abroad but not necessary. Does anybody have any experience staying or traveling to these places? That could give recommendations on where to stay or what to do.