Do either of these work on me?

Having a small dinner out later this week for my birthday and got 2 dresses to possibly wear. Not sure if it’s just me being picky but they both somehow look ‘off’ to me.

Red? Pink? Or scrap them both and just wear some jeans or something 😭

Edit: will not be wearing the smartwatch and beaded bracelets the day of lol just had them on when I took these

Edit 2: ugh forgot men are allowed to comment here 🤦🏻‍♀️ so to all of them having an issue—the whole point of both of them is to be fitted and short, and I’m 24 so any comments about not being age appropriate will be swiftly ignored ❤️