•1 min read•from Machine Learning
How exactly does the NeurIPS meta reviewer response work? [D]
We can currently answer the meta-reviewer via AC confidential comment, but they just posted the following tweet:
https://x.com/neuripsconf/status/2081991451236319328?s=46&t=HWfJoLgHxGH2W5l-o3mPJw
Where it says:
“Please post your answers to the Area Chair's initial-meta reviews via a comment from July 28th and by August 3rd, so that reviewers can see it too.”
Is this option going to open up today as the rebuttal period ends? Is this where the meta-reviewer rebuttal should be posted? Or are we supposed to finalize the discussions and inform the AC at the end, stating what happened basically? It is all quite confusing.
[link] [comments]
Want to read more?
Check out the full article on the original site
Tagged with
#NeurIPS
#meta-reviewer
#Area Chair
#rebuttal
#review process
#confidential comment
#AC
#submission
#initial review
#finalization
#discussion
#July 28th
#August 3rd
#machine learning
#reviewers
#tweet
#research
#academic conference
#peer review