•1 min read•from Machine Learning
Neurips 2026: does every metareview recommend accept/reject? [D]
I see some people say their metareview already contains a decision/recommendation (all of them were rejections). Ours doesn’t. Even though our avg score is 3, the metareview seems optimistic and finishes with “a convincing response would be an important consideration while discussing the paper.” I wonder how to interpret that. We did a strong rebuttal, but none of the reviewers engaged. So I wonder whether there’s any point to keep hope due to the AC review or just give up.
[link] [comments]
Want to read more?
Check out the full article on the original site
Tagged with
#NeurIPS
#metareview
#accept/reject
#decision
#recommendation
#rebuttal
#reviewers
#AC review
#average score
#optimistic
#convincing response
#machine learning
#paper
#hope
#engagement
#consideration
#discussing
#submissions
#peer review
#Neurips 2026