•1 min read•from Machine Learning
Missing Feedback Raises Questions in NeurIPS Paper Rejections
Do all the rejected or accepted papers get a "Final Justification" comment from the PC?
Mine got rejected with ratings 4-4-4 yet the meta review is the exact same as the one that was posted originally in July and I didn't get any final comment. I find it a bit harsh especially since in the rejection e-mail they state how much effort they asked AC and SAC for careful reviewing and useful feedback, "especially in borderline cases"...
[link] [comments]
Want to read more?
Check out the full article on the original site
Tagged with
#NeurIPS
#rejection
#final justification
#PC
#meta review
#AC
#SAC
#reviewing
#feedback
#borderline cases
#ratings
#machine learning
#effort
#paper
#justification
#submission
#review
#accepted
#harsh